Hard Times - Business Ethics and Happiness
Hard Times (1854)
Written by the English novelist, Charles Dickens (1812-70) as a criticism
1. Free market economics
(based on profit, self-interest, worker exploitation and the ideas of Adam Smith, pictured right above)
The belief that only useful things are valuable with the possible exclusion of the arts, creative
imagination and human kindness
This was supported by the English philosophers:
- Jeremy Bentham,pictured right below.
- Dickens’s most vicious attack on the exploitation of factory workers in Victorian Britain.
- Made into a 1994 BBC TV serial starring Alan Bates as Josiah Bounderby.
Who was the book dedicated to?
The Scottish philosopher, Thomas Carlyle (1795-1881), pictured right, who (like
Dickens) hated the ruthless pursuit of profit.
Thomas Gradgrind, rich, retired merchant with five children
Louisa and Tom, his oldest children
Josiah Bounderby, his friend and rich factory owner
Stephen Blackpool, a worker in Bounderby’s factory
Sissy, a poor circus girl
Thomas Gradgrind is a rich, retired merchant in the industrial city of
Coketown in northern England, becoming its Member of Parliament.
He removes any fun and imagination from the upbringing of his children, Louisa and
Tom, and the education of the pupils in the school he finances.
But he looks after the poor (but kind) Sissy after her father,a circus performer,
disappears. Gradgrind hates the circus, because he thinks it's frivolous and damagingly useless.
Louisa marries the much older Josiah Bounderby, the rich banker and owner of a cotton mill,
where the kind Stephen Blackpool works.
Stephen falls in love with another poor worker, Rachael, but he is married and stays loyal to
his horrible and drunken wife.
Stephen refuses to strike or join a trade (or labour) union, led by
Slackbridge, because he thinks a strike would harm relations between management and workers.
Stephen is shunned by his fellow workers and fired by Bounderby when he refuses to spy on them. Louisa gives him
some money, but Stephen is accused of a bank robbery after Tom tells him to be where it
A young, wealthy Member of Parliament, James Harthouse, declares his love for Louisa (pictured
right together in the BBC production)
Louisa rushes to her father, Gradgrind, telling him about her unhappy childhood and terrible marriage with
Bounderby. Gradgrind realizes the mistakes he has made.
Sissy persuades Harthouse to save Louisa from disgrace and heartache by leaving her. Bounderby is furious about
their friendship, making him more determined to capture Stephen with the help of his evil housekeeper, Mrs
Sparsit, who jealously hates Louisa.
Stephen falls into a coal mine on his way to Coketown to clear his name and dies with Rachael who (helped by
Sissy and Louisa) has found him.
Louisa and Rachael now realize that Tom was responsible for the bank robbery. They help
him to escape abroad with the assistance of Sissy’s old circus friends.
Mrs Pegler, Bounderby’s loving mother, reveals that his impoverished and neglected upbringing
is a lie.
Five years later Bounderby dies alone and unhappy, unlike the transformed Gradgrind who is now
devoting his life to the poor. He changes when Louisa tells him that his loveless philosophy has always made her
Tom is penitent about his past crimes but dies heartbroken, separated from Louisa.
Louisa never marries again, or has children, but is taught to love others through Sissy’s love and happy
Lessons for business ethics and happiness
1. Employees are people with feelings
Dickens (pictured right) called the book, Hard Times, because factory workers were so badly treated by
businessmen like Gradgrind and Bounderby.
But Dickens was against trade unions.
Dickens (like Stephen Blackpool) thought that workers and management should resolve their differences through
compassionately satisfying workers' needs, not
- acceptance of ill treatment by employers.
Rachael comments to Bounderby on how Stephen stood up to both him and the union:
“The masters against him on one hand, the men against him on the other, he only wantin to work hard in peace,
and do what he felt right. Can a man have no soul of his own, no mind of his own?”
2. Protect the poor
Dickens championed the rights of the weak and oppressed like Stephen Blackpool, Sissy and Louisa.
People did boring work 15 hours a day in a polluted city and poor
But the library provided relief, because:
“Fiction gives them relaxation and braces them for their daily routine”, Dickens says
3. Stand up for your principles
Stephen Blackpool is a hero because he stands by his moral ideals of honesty, humanity,
compassion and integrity, even when they bring him:
- unpopularity amongst his fellow workers.
He loves Rachael but remains loyal to his horrible wife.
Stephen (Bill Paterson) is pictured right above in the 1994 production.
4. Learning is fun and worthwhile
Children’s education in Gradgrind’s school is made boring, unimaginative and uncreative through:
- strict discipline.
- rote learning (and unquestioning acceptance) of facts
Gradgrind doesn’t believe in fun, making Tom and Louisa’s childhood miserable. They love the circus, because
it's fun and stimulates their imagination.
Gradgrind (Bob Peck, pictured right, in the 1994 BBC production with Bounderby, left):
- eventually recognizes the importance of love, fun and imagination.
5. Love is all
The book shows that life without love is worthless, even if you have lots of
Sissy, Rachael, Stephen and Louisa (pictured right with James Harthouse in the BBC
production) are all heroes because their hearts are full of kindness for others.
Stephen loved Rachael because her selfless love changed him “from bad to good”.
The unhappiest character, Bounderby, is selfish, insensitive and
a ruthless businessman. Louisa doesn't love him, but marries him to please her father,
Gradgrind, Bounderby's friend.
Tom's crime means that he dies hearbroken without Louisa, whom he loves more than
6. Principle before profit
Money and profit are Bounderby’s idols and his relationships suffer because of it (particularly with Louisa and
Bounderby (Alan Bates in the 1994 BBC production, pictured right) is:
- a “bully of humility” (using his fake deprived upbringing to attack people).
- finally revealed as a fraud.
Gradgrind redeemed himself by:
“making his facts and figures subservient to faith, hope and charity” .
7. Happy people talk to and understand each
Louisa and Bounderby are unhappy because they don’t talk to (and so understand) each
Gradgrind is so focused on his own views that he fails to see that he has made Louisa so unhappy
But Sissy is great with people, persuading Harthouse to leave and organzing the discovery of Stephen.
Sissy (Emma Lewis) is pictured right in the 1994 BBC production.
Key quotes on decision making
Facts alone are wanted in life, Thomas Gradgrind
I always come to a decision...and whatever I do, I
do at once, Bounderby.
Key quote on wisdom
Some persons hold ... that there is a wisdom of the head, and that there is a wisdom of the heart,
Key quotes on workers and trade unions
The masters against him on one hand, the
men against him on the other, he only wantin to work hard in peace, and do what he felt right. Can a man have no
soul of his own, no mind of his own?, Rachael (talking about Stephen).
I tell you that the hour is come, when we must rally one another as one united power and crumble into dust the
oppressors that too long have battened upon the plunder of our families, upon the sweat of our brows ... ,
Two literature websites to
A big thank you to...
The BBC for the pictures.